Our chefs specialize in authentic and delicious Sandwiches food. The staff at J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop is devoted to serving customers mouthwatering dishes that feature the highest quality ingredients available. Turkey Sandwich, Grilled Chicken Sandwich and Roast Beef Sandwich are all prepared quickly and delivered to you right away.
J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop uses only the freshest ingredients around, ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Not sure what you're in the mood for? Try one of our specialties including Pastrami Sandwich , Ham Sandwich, , , and more.
Another solid Yelp reco for lunch in my new neighborhood. Wasn't looking to drop $$ (which appears to be very possible in Midtown) and get something not-too-heavy... and since many of my fellow Yelp friends have been here (s/o to Taric), I was pointed to McGurkee's! Not even $8 spent on a sandwich, potato salad and a pickle.
I've passed by the intersection a few times in years past but never noticed this unassuming small shop. Parking is a little rough BUT McGurkee's doesn't have much seating to begin with so...
As Taric and a few others mentioned, they don't have pizza. The menu has shrank to just one side (subs and sandwiches). Every table was full when I walked in so you know having a small menu is A-OK. The cashier/server was super sweet, she recommended the Super Scilian based on what I've ordered at a national sub shop. That sandwich bread is bomb dot com- hours later and I don't feel blah like I would after eating other bread. The pickle and potato salad (chips are also an option) are a nice side.... Not overly mayo-heavy. Can't wait to try another sandwich next time I'm in the 'hood.
The service is great and the food is really great and the ulterior atmosphere is really nice and I like it very small and quaint. Menu prices are her very affordable and set my budget very well.
Needed lunch & wanted to get out of house. Took Lyft over. Ordered the deluxe Italian sub...so this took me back to my childhood my mom would pick up these toasted Italian subs which had side of dressing that you poured over the sub & those tangy pepperoncinis...amazing, amazing...cute back patio & inside restaurant adorable & eclectic....weather amazing back patio is small but quaint... my only negative was ice tea tasted stale which maybe the tea machine needs a good cleaning otherwise the sub was so good I just had to do the 5 stars